Zero Tolerance and Rules from the Ivory Tower
Posted by Jim Palmer, The Newsletter Guru on Tuesday, February 16th, 2010In my former life as a regional manager, I had both ‘corporate office’ experience and I was also active in the field, working with the same stores and employees that I had come up through. This ‘front line’ experience helped me to appreciate the silly and often ridiculous ways that those at corporate, you might say, the Ivory Tower, would interfere with the company’s real mission which is to grow the business by meeting and exceeding customer expectations. Twenty five years in retail has ingrained in me an ability to spot stupidity a mile away, as I did last week.
I was on a tight schedule as usual and one of my stops was at my personal bank to deposit a check. I pulled in to the drive through and after waiting almost 10 minutes the attendant returned to tell me that they couldn’t deposit my check because it looked altered. What?
It was my own company check, written by me to myself, to be deposited (not cashed!) into the personal checking account I had with this bank. It seems that the bank has a policy of not accepting checks that may appear to be altered. At first glance this seems like a worthwhile safety policy for all concerned, but what were they objecting to?
The clerk explained that the date looked altered. They said that they couldn’t tell if the date was February 12 or 13! It was not altered, perhaps my messy handwriting, but in either case, what difference could this possible make, it was February 13? At this point I wasn’t mad, I was stunned in disbelief.
I realized that the clerk was just following orders and not the one to be upset with so I asked if the manager was inside. He said that she was but that she already OK’d this! “Tell her I’ll be right in.”
I drove around, parked and went inside where the manager was waiting for me. She re-explained the banks policy and showed me that the date on my check was not clear! Since it was already February 13 I asked what possible difference it could make and she just repeated the banks ‘no alterations’ policy. Now I was getting streamed.
Here are the facts as I explained them to the branch manager.
• You know me by sight as one of your customers
• You personally opened up our checking and savings accounts
• You processed our home equity loan six months ago
• You know that I own my own business, that this is my company check, written by me
• And finally, I’m not looking to withdraw money; I’m depositing this money into your bank!
No dice. I had to drive home, write another check and come back. Despite my growing red face I still recognized that even the branch manager was not the policy maker so I asked who was and if we could get them on the phone. Surprisingly she obliged and she got the banks controller on the phone to clarify their ‘no alterations’ policy. Having told the controller the facts as I just outlined above, the branch manager then said to the ‘Ivory Tower’ controller that even though I know Jim, if I accept this check I will be written up, right? She was told, “Yes you will.”
And there you have it. The branch manager was afraid for her job and the result was one of major inconvenience for a good customer. By the way, this bank has also been courting me to move my business banking to their bank. Not going to happen.
This is yet another example of a policy created in the Ivory Tower, combined with zero tolerance for any common sense to be applied by the folks entrusted to actually interact with and serve their customers. It’s no wonder so many businesses are in serious trouble.
Many times policies are created in the ivory tower in the heat of the moment, when something bad or unfortunate happens at the store level. Typically, the policies created are an over reaction to something that rarely happens and in fact create impediments to customers trying to do business. A couple questions for you as I close this rant.
• Do you have any of these policies in your business?
• Do you trust your front line staff to do what’s necessary to serve and please your customers?
Remember, customers have many options. Make it easy for your customers to do business with you. By the way, when I left the bank I drive to another location less than 2 miles away and they immediately deposited my check!











